Keep Your Gold Leaf Off My Pie Table

Keep Your Gold Leaf Off My Pie Table

Babette Pepaj

A $150 Thanksgiving pie is trending on LinkedIn right now. It has a Cinnamon Toast Crunch crust, an apple cider caramel swirl, and gold leaf on top. Actual gold. The kind of thing you’d expect on a picture frame or a czar. The New York Times wrote a whole story about it, and the story also contains a $120 pie finished with beeswax sabayon and a $70 pecan pie that ships in a pine box and might contain a golden ticket redeemable for a diamond bracelet, a sentence I have now read five times and it has not improved. I did a double take at the headline. Then I read the article. And now it is Sunday evening, a day offering a person any number of reasonable activities, and I am spending mine writing about pie. I want that on the record before I say anything else, because it tells you exactly who you’re dealing with.

I have loved pie my whole life, and my whole life, pie has loved me back by staying affordable. My first was a McDonald’s cherry pie, eaten at an age when I assumed all pie came through a window. Then the apple, the original recipe, and if you’re old enough to remember the original recipe you just nodded. From there I graduated to Marie Callender’s, where I would walk in and stand in front of the pie case the way other people stand in front of paintings. Years later I seduced my husband with a lemon meringue pie, and only after I made it did I learn it had been his father’s favorite, a fact nobody told me and I could not possibly have known. The pie knew. I married him. You don’t argue with results like that.

So Thanksgiving, for me, is not about the turkey. It’s about the pie table, and I will tell you something about my pie table that the gold leaf people are not going to like: some of my favorite pies on it come from Costco. The pumpkin pie weighs over three pounds, feeds twelve, and costs about seven dollars. The lattice apple weighs four pounds, which is not a pie, that is a commitment, and it’s still under fifteen. There is a three-pound Reese’s chocolate peanut butter pie whose official serving size is one forty-eighth of the pie. One forty-eighth. Whoever calculated that has never met a human being, and I admire the optimism. When you walk into a party carrying one of these, people notice, and what they are noticing is generosity, because that pie says I brought enough for everyone, go back for seconds, I’ll get another one. Buried in the Times story, almost as an afterthought, is the fact that Costco sells about nine million of those pumpkin pies a year. Nine million. The $150 pie got the headline. The seven-dollar pie got America.

But something is off this year, and I’ve been noticing it from my car. Lines. Long ones, wrapped around the block, for Greek frozen yogurt, directly next to restaurants with open tables and a host staring out the window like a lighthouse keeper. Candace Nelson, who founded Sprinkles and spent years on the other end of a famous line, just wrote about this in her newsletter. A restaurant consultant once told her never to show an open 7:30 reservation online, because if you can get the table, you no longer want the table. She also admitted that her own legendary line, the one people accused her of engineering on purpose, was never a strategy. It was a bakery that was small because small was what she could afford, and one exhausted woman inside frosting as fast as humanly possible. From the sidewalk, a line looks like success. From inside, it’s somebody drowning in buttercream.

That’s the economy the $150 pie was born into, and that’s why it exists. Not because anyone was lying awake wishing their pie crust tasted more like a breakfast cereal, but because we’ve trained ourselves to want whatever is hard to get, and pie had the nerve to still be easy. The croissant got elevated. Coffee got elevated. Bagels in certain zip codes now require planning, an alarm, and a small loan. Pie was the last one standing there in a window, priced like food, asking nothing of you but a fork. Apparently that could not be allowed to continue. Now it has gold on it, and in Texas it has jewelry inside, and somewhere a pastry chef is explaining that if you really break down the numbers, it’s not that crazy.

It’s a little crazy. And here’s what the numbers people will never break down correctly: the pie table doesn’t work on scarcity, it works on the opposite. Everything on it was either made by someone who loves you or bought by someone who wanted to make sure there was plenty. The homemade lemon meringue sits next to the Costco pumpkin and nobody checks a price tag, because the only question anyone asks at a pie table is whether all of them can fit on one plate. The answer, every year, is yes, if you believe in yourself.

Now stop reading this and go make a pie. Not someday. Tonight, or at the latest Tuesday, because Thanksgiving is coming and it will judge you. Go buy butter, flour, and whatever fruit makes eye contact with you in the produce aisle. Don’t overthink the fruit. Apples have been carrying this operation for three hundred years, they can carry you too. Your kitchen will become a crime scene. There will be flour in places flour has never been and will never fully leave. Your crust will tear, and you will patch it with a scrap of dough and your thumb, and that patch will be the best bite in the whole pie, because that’s the spot where anyone can see a human was here. And then the smell starts, and there is no candle, no spa, no luxury good on this earth that has successfully imitated a pie in the oven. Companies have tried. They have failed. They know.

Can’t bake? Won’t bake? Still invited. Drive to a pie shop, a real one, and stand in front of the case the way I stood at Marie Callender’s, because looking at a pie case is the last free luxury in America. Or grab the three-pound Costco pumpkin and carry it into the party with both hands like a championship belt. And if you want to bake but crust scares you, ask BakeBot (or BakeBot on BakeSpace). I built it for exactly this, and it has never once made anybody stand in a line.

Because pie was never supposed to be hard to get. That was the whole gift of it. So bring the homemade one with the thumb patch, bring the three-pound giant, bring both, it’s Thanksgiving, nobody is counting. And if someone actually shows up holding the $150 pie with the gold leaf on it, let them in. Set it down next to the Costco pumpkin and cut it into forty-eight slices so everybody gets a bite, because that’s what a pie table does: whatever walks in acting precious leaves as dessert. Happy Thanksgiving. Save me a slice. Actually, save me several. You know exactly who you’re dealing with.

Back to blog

SHARE THIS PAGE:

1 of 4